You can’t mourn the loss of community while admiring the barricades you built to keep it out.
In our previous exploration of modern friendship and community, we introduced the concept of exquisite loneliness, a peculiar modern affliction where chosen solitude transforms into an aestheticised lifestyle.
While Part 1 examined why friendship feels impossible in our modern age, this piece delves deeper into the psychology of beautiful isolation itself: why we’re drawn to it, how it becomes our identity and how to break free from it, even when it feels almost like betraying ourselves.
Exquisite loneliness and the lack of community isn’t just something that happens to us. It’s something we have actively cultivated, curated and perhaps most dangerously, fallen in love with.
When Comfort Becomes Confinement
In 1969, Patrick Goldring wrote a social commentary called “The Broilerhouse Society” where he compared modern citizens to factory-farmed chickens. The metaphor remains uncomfortably relevant today.
Free-range chickens are allowed to roam freely all day. They interact with the natural world and are aware of time and the seasons passing throughout their lives. Broilerhouse chickens on the other hand are hatched and raised under tightly controlled conditions. Climate, time, even night and day are artificially controlled. Despite having everything controlled for them and in perfect measures, they overall live far more stressed lives than their free-range cousins.
Goldring’s observation was prescient. The modern person may live a life which is increasingly better organised and more efficient but it is also becoming as tasteless and flavourless as the supermarket Meal Deal sandwich they eat for lunch at their desk. The average person’s home today is not their castle. Instead, it is their bright and centrally-heated nesting-cage.
Goldring mourned the loss of communal third places such as cinemas and visits to the pub, as well as the unscripted interactions that can happen in these places. As homes have become more beautiful, more personalised and more controlled, public spaces seem to have degenerated into unwelcoming, featureless bores. We have begun associating home with safety and cleanliness and public space as chaotic, dirty or ugly. By extension, we view the people outside our homes, our neighbours, strangers, the broader community and perhaps even our friends, as similarly chaotic and undesirable.
This is where exquisite loneliness begins to take shape. We’ve built ourselves the perfect broilerhouse.
The Aesthetic and Addiction of Absence
Exquisite loneliness has a particular look. You know it when you see it: the perfectly unmade bed with expensive linen sheets and a stack of unread novels. The single wine glass on a marble countertop. The Instagram story of rain against a window with no caption needed. The meme about staying in bed while everyone else is out with friends.
It’s a type of loneliness with production value that says, “I’m different, but you wouldn’t understand”.
Unlike regular loneliness, which feels raw and desperate, exquisite loneliness feels sophisticated and recherché. It whispers that you’re too deep, too sensitive, too evolved for the shallow connections everyone else seems to settle for. Unlike everyone else, you’re discerning and selective. You (in the words of social media’s favourite phrase) “protect your peace”.
Social media has perfected this aesthetic. We’ve learned to make loneliness look aspirational and in doing so, we’ve made it dangerously addictive.
The Seduction of Superior Suffering
True loneliness can affect us all but there’s a particular type of person who becomes susceptible to exquisite loneliness. It’s often someone who has always felt slightly different. Maybe you were the sensitive child, the one who would rather stay at home than go to your friends’ birthday parties. Perhaps you’ve always been told you’re “mature for your age” or “an old soul.” You learnt early on that being alone felt safer than risking misunderstanding.
Exquisite loneliness offers us something irresistible: a way to transform our outsider status into spiritual superiority.
Psychologist Gabor Maté writes about how we often develop coping mechanisms in childhood that serve us initially but become prisons in adulthood. For many people, withdrawal becomes their primary strategy for avoiding emotional pain. But exquisite loneliness goes further – it transforms withdrawal into an art form.
The narrative becomes: I’m authentically myself in a world of performative people. I don’t struggle with connection; I simply require a deeper level of understanding that most people can’t provide.” This reframing is intoxicating because it takes your deepest insecurity, the fear that you don’t belong, and flips it into evidence of your superiority.
The Identity Trap
Perhaps the most insidious aspect of exquisite loneliness is how it gradually becomes who you are rather than just what you’re experiencing.
At first, it might be temporary: “I’m taking some time for myself.” Then it becomes circumstantial: “I’m just in a phase where I need space.” Eventually, it becomes definitional: “I’m someone who prefers my own company.”
The shift is subtle but significant. When loneliness becomes identity, any attempt to change it feels like betraying yourself. Research suggests we often create rigid identities around our coping mechanisms. The person who prides themselves on being “independent” may struggle to ask for help. The person who sees themselves as “low-maintenance” may struggle to express needs. Similarly, the person who has built an identity around sophisticated solitude may find it terrifying to admit they actually just find it hard and messy to maintain friendships.
One of the most seductive aspects of exquisite loneliness is how it protects you from the unpredictability of human connection. When you’re alone, you can’t be rejected, misunderstood or disappointed by others. You may feel empty but you also feel safe.
There’s a particular comfort in controlled disappointment. When you spend Saturday night alone, you can romanticise it as a choice. When someone cancels plans on you, it doesn’t sting the same way because you didn’t really want to go anyway. Equally, when you scroll through photos of friends having fun without you, you can tell yourself you wouldn’t have enjoyed it in the first place.
Exquisite loneliness becomes a kind of emotional insurance policy. You may not get the highs of genuine connection but you also avoid the lows of social rejection. The problem is that this insurance policy comes with a premium: you pay with your capacity for spontaneous joy, unexpected intimacy and the irreplaceable experience of being truly known by another person.
Community is Inconvenient
People trapped in exquisite loneliness often develop a mythology around connection and community. They believe that somewhere out there exists their “person” or “tribe”: People who will immediately understand them without the awkward work of actually getting to know each other. These people will magically appreciate their depth, match their intellect and love them exactly as they are without any of the friction that characterises real relationships. This mythology is particularly appealing because it allows you to remain open to connection in theory while completely avoiding it in practice.
The tragedy is that this perfect person or tribe rarely exists – or perhaps they do, but you won’t find them by closing yourself off. Perfect understanding isn’t how human connection works. Real intimacy is built through a thousand small moments of misunderstanding and repair, not through immediate recognition. It’s messy, imperfect and requires the very vulnerability that exquisite loneliness is designed to avoid.
While exquisite loneliness may feel sophisticated and self-protective, it comes with costs that aren’t immediately visible:
1. Emotional Atrophy
Like muscles that weaken from disuse, our capacity for connection diminishes when we don’t practice it. Social skills require maintenance. The longer you spend in beautiful isolation, the more daunting re-entry becomes.
2. Distorted Reality
When most of your social interaction happens through curated online content, you lose touch with the ordinary messiness of human relationships. Everyone else’s connections start to look effortless and perfect, making your own social anxiety feel more unusual than it actually is.
3. Creative Stagnation
While solitude can be creatively fertile, exquisite loneliness often becomes creatively stagnant. Instead of using alone time for growth or creation, it becomes focused on maintaining the aesthetic of interesting isolation and hoping people notice your absence.
4. Compound Loneliness
Perhaps most importantly, exquisite loneliness tends to reinforce itself. The longer you spend alone, the more “other” everyone else starts to feel. What begins as a preference slowly calcifies into a kind of social agoraphobia.
Breaking the Beautiful Spell
Genuine community and friendship are inherently inconvenient. Community requires inconvenience, sacrifice and a rejection of comfort. There’s simply no way around it.
But these inconveniences aren’t unfortunate byproducts of community. They are community. They are what create depth. And if you’re lucky, your community may reciprocate but if not, the uncertainty of whether this relationship is one-sided is also a part of community. It’s the inconvenience and unpredictability of connection that makes it meaningful. It’s a gamble that doesn’t always pay off, we grant you, but when it does, the prize is worth far more than the tribulations.
So what can we do to build a community and make friendship feel real again? Here are five ways we believe might help. It’s by no means an exhaustive list but it’s a start.
1. Let friendship develop slowly
Friendships can begin anywhere: at the gym, work, a weekly art group. The more open you are, the more likely you are to find people you connect with. Not everyone will become a close friend and that’s fine. Be warm. Be kind. Don’t treat people like Pokémon to collect or assume you’re unworthy just because you have nothing obvious to “offer.”
And if something clicks, you don’t need to rush. Real connection takes time. Let the friendship steep and mature gently like a good cup of tea.
2. Make room for uncurated time
Let go of the urge to document everything. Choose meetups that aren’t “content-worthy” such as quiet walks and board game nights. The kind of memories that never make it onto stories but somehow end up mattering more.
3. Unfollow them on social media
We know it seems like we suggest this in every blog we write but it’s for a good reason.
There’s nothing more deflating than sharing something joyful in person, only to hear: “Yeah, I saw it on Instagram.” What follows is usually an evening spent half-scrolling, half-present – checking in on other people instead of each other.
If you’re going to unfollow a friend, tell them why. Let them know it’s not about shutting them out but about showing up better when you’re together. That you want your real-life moments to feel more present, not pre-processed.
Once you’ve disconnected, do something different: write them a note. Post a card. In an age of instant everything, there’s something almost radical about choosing the slow and thoughtful route.
4. If there was a misunderstanding, say sorry. Properly.
Not “Sorry you felt that way.” Just sorry. No qualifiers.
It’s an underrated superpower in a world where ego often shouts louder than empathy.
5. Celebrate each other’s successes (and practise confelicity)
Don’t be the friend who spends the entire evening talking about themselves, leaving others wondering, “Did they even learn a single thing about me?”
Share your joys and experiences but make space to ask about theirs too – and genuinely celebrate them.
Empathy isn’t just about shared sorrow. It’s also about shared joy. Confelicity, from the Latin for “shared happiness,” is just as vital to friendship as compassion (from the Latin for “shared pain”).
Both say the same thing: your emotions matter to me too.
Conclusion: The Courage to Be Ordinary
Perhaps the most radical act for someone trapped in exquisite loneliness is choosing to be ordinary. We often see the internet cliché “I’m not like other girls”, but what might happen if we were? What if we showed up imperfectly and risked being misunderstood? What could happen if we did the mundane work of actually getting to know people instead of waiting to be discovered?
At worst, you might meet a few new people who you never speak to again. At best, it might mean recognising that the person you become in an authentic community is even more interesting and altruistic than the person you’ve been protecting in beautiful solitude all this time.
Feeling inspired to reconnect with your friends on a deeper level? Explore our notebooks, cards and thoughtful gifts designed to bring people a little closer.